Keep or Switch the Seller's Insurance Broker?

Change brokers when you can name a specific gap between what your company needs and what your broker delivers, and time the move for a natural moment: your first 90 days, or 90 to 120 days ahead of renewal. Buying the business is not, by itself, a reason to switch. The seller's broker may have served the company well, so test fit before you move. This guide is for anyone who just bought a company and is deciding whether to keep the seller's broker, from first-time searchers to holding company operators.

The short answer

Switch for a documented reason, such as missing market access, slow closing-day work, no real review of what you inherited, or unclear answers on role and pay.
Do not switch only because a renewal went up, a pitch sounded good or the broker was the seller's. Ask for a written explanation first.
The easiest windows are your first 90 days and about 90 to 120 days before renewal. Mid-term switches are possible, but insurer rules differ.
A broker of record (BOR) letter is meant to move servicing, not coverage terms, but some insurers cancel and rewrite a policy when it takes effect. Ask each insurer before you sign.
Plan the handover: collect documents, tell the incumbent yourself, protect claims-made history and keep certificates flowing.

Should I change brokers just because I bought the business?

No. Ownership changed, but the policies, the insurers and the people who know the account may all still be useful. Your options are to keep the broker, keep it and add a second opinion on specific lines, or replace it. If you add a second broker, split the work by line or by insurer and put it in writing, because insurers generally accept an account from one broker at a time and two approaches to the same insurer can lock both out.

Two facts help. First, a broker changes who advises and services you. By itself it does not change what a policy says, although a few insurers rewrite a policy when a broker changes (see below). Second, how you bought matters. In an asset purchase you usually need new policies at closing anyway. In a stock purchase the policies often stay in force for now, so you can decide at your own pace, but check each policy's change in control and notice terms first, because some claims-made policies narrow at closing. The related guides on the seller's broker versus your own and keeping the seller's insurance go deeper on both.

What are good reasons to change brokers?

A good reason is specific, written down and testable. Use the table to name yours, then run the test in the right-hand column before you act. A failed test gives you evidence for the conversation with the incumbent, and a passed test may tell you to stay.

Good reasons to change brokers and how to test each one first
Reason	What it looks like	Test before you switch
Market access does not match the business	The broker can quote only one or two insurers for operations you now run, or cannot say which markets it approached	Ask which insurers it approached at the last renewal and why. See admitted versus surplus lines markets
Slow or inaccurate on deadlines	Binders (written proof that coverage is in force), certificates or lender evidence arrive late or with errors	Log the dates of three requests and ask for a written fix plan
No real review of what you inherited	Only the declarations page was read, and there is no gap list	Ask for a written review of the full policies and endorsements, as in a business insurance review
Your structure changed	You added companies, a board with investors, new states or a new lender, and the broker has not handled that before	Ask how it handled the same change for another client, without names
Unclear role or pay	The broker cannot say whom it represents, how it is paid or whether pay varies by insurer	Ask in writing. See how insurance brokers get paid
Licensing gap	The firm or person is not licensed for the line you need in the state that governs your placement (usually where the insured is located)	Check your state insurance department's license lookup, ask which state license the broker relies on and ask for the National Producer Number (NPN)

Rules on disclosing role and pay differ by state. New York and California each address it in their own way, so ask wherever you are: how are you paid, and does it vary by insurer? (Sources are listed below.)

What are weak reasons to change brokers?

A renewal increase alone. Price follows loss history, payroll, business changes and the market. Ask for a written explanation of what moved. No new broker can promise a lower price.
One slow reply. Look for a pattern across several requests before you act.
A polished pitch with no review. See red flags in an insurance broker for fair tests.
Pressure from the seller, or loyalty to the seller. Decide on fit for your company.

When is the best time to switch?

The best time is a moment when a handover costs little. The table lists the common windows. The 90 to 120 day lead before renewal is a practical suggestion, not an industry rule.

Common windows to change brokers
Window	Why it can work	Watch out for
Before closing (choosing rather than switching)	You can pick your own broker to price the program and prepare closing-day binders. In an asset purchase the policies are new anyway, and in a stock purchase a BOR comes later	The broker needs the seller's documents, so ask deal counsel what the confidentiality terms allow
First 90 days	The review is happening anyway, and urgent items are being fixed	Do not drop the workers' compensation ownership change report. Many policies require it within 90 days
About 90 to 120 days before renewal	Time to go back to market with a full submission, and a clean break at renewal	You will need loss runs and submission data. The incumbent may share them, and you can usually request loss runs from each insurer directly, so ask early. Renewal dates are fixed
Mid-term	A service failure cannot wait for renewal	Insurer rules differ, and some cancel and rewrite the policy
During an open claim	Only if service on the claim is failing	The insurer handles the claim, and a new broker does not move it. Keep the adjuster's contact details

On the ownership change report, in states that follow the National Council on Compensation Insurance (NCCI) manual, and several others such as Massachusetts and Pennsylvania, the policy requires the report within 90 days. Ohio, Washington, North Dakota and Wyoming use state funds with their own rules, so ask which applies. The same trade-offs are covered in when to remarket: mid-term or at renewal.

What happens to my policies when I switch brokers?

A broker of record (BOR) letter is your signed instruction to an insurer appointing a new broker on an existing policy, often on your letterhead or the ACORD 36 form.

It is meant to change who services the policy, not its terms, and it applies where the policies stay in force, usually after a stock purchase. Some insurers cancel and rewrite the policy when the change takes effect, and a premium-financed policy adds the finance agreement to the question. A new broker can also service only insurers it can reach, directly or through a wholesaler (a specialty intermediary that retail brokers use to reach some insurers).

Ask each insurer before you sign. The mechanics are in broker of record letters: switching brokers without switching policies.

How do I hand over while limiting coverage gaps?

Write down why you are switching, using the table above.
Ask the incumbent for a document set. Full policies with endorsements, loss runs, open claims with adjuster contacts, the certificate log and renewal dates. See documents for an insurance review.
Hold a fair selection. Ask every candidate the same written questions: which insurers would you approach for my account and why (the incumbent can also say which it approached at last renewal), who handles my certificates, what would be on your gap list once you have my policies, how are you paid, and what do you do in the first 24 hours of a claim. The longer list is in questions to ask an insurance broker.
Tell the incumbent yourself before any letter arrives, then follow the BOR steps in the guide above.
Protect claims-made history. A change of broker alone should not change a policy's retroactive date (the earliest date of work or acts it covers), but a cancel-and-rewrite or a move to a different insurer can. Before a claims-made policy moves, ask how the retroactive date carries over and whether a tail is needed. Get the answer in writing. See prior acts and tail coverage after an acquisition.
Confirm in writing which policies moved, the effective date and whether any were cancelled and rewritten. A quote is not proof that coverage is in force.
Keep the routines running. Send lenders the new contact and update certificate holders. See certificate tracking in your first month.
Check again after 30 days. Do the endorsements still show, and did the new broker deliver a gap list?

A hypothetical example. An owner closes a stock purchase and the policies renew in five months. The seller's broker answers a request for a written review with a renewal summary but no written gap list, so the owner sends the same five written questions to that broker and to one other firm, and sets a decision date about 120 days before renewal. If the incumbent answers well, the owner keeps it and schedules a six-month check-in. If not, the owner authorizes the new broker in writing to approach insurers, and signs a BOR letter for the current policies about 100 days before renewal, only after asking each insurer when the change takes effect and whether it cancels and rewrites. Loss runs come from the incumbent or each insurer.

Could Morrow be a second opinion?

Morrow is an independent insurance agency in Boston that focuses on business insurance, and the brand of Afthonea Inc. If you want a second opinion before deciding, it can review the policies you inherited, flag gaps and request quotes from insurers. A review does not commit you to switching. It does not issue policies or decide coverage, and any new terms depend on carrier underwriting. A quote or a review request is not bound coverage. Morrow is licensed in these states only: Arizona, California, Colorado, Florida, Georgia, Illinois, Louisiana, Massachusetts, Michigan, Nevada, New Jersey, New York, North Carolina, Ohio, Pennsylvania, South Carolina, Texas and Virginia.

Keeping your current broker may be the better choice if it passes the tests above, if your state is not on that list, or if you need life, disability or health benefits advice. Ask your attorney about the purchase agreement and your accountant about tax questions.

Keep reading

Frequently asked questions

Is it too late to change brokers once my policies are in force?

No. You can move servicing mid-term with a broker of record letter, or wait for renewal. Insurer rules differ, so ask each one how it handles the change.

Will changing brokers cancel my insurance?

It depends on the insurer. A broker of record change is meant to appoint a new broker on an existing policy, and some insurers keep the policy in force. Others cancel and rewrite it on the effective date, which can create a new short-term policy. Ask each insurer before you sign and get written confirmation afterward.

Do I need the seller's broker to agree before I switch?

Usually not, but check each insurer. The insured signs the letter, yet insurers commonly notify the incumbent and give it a short window, set by each insurer, to respond or rescind. A courteous conversation first helps you get loss runs and open claim contacts.

Should I change brokers before closing or after?

It depends on the deal. Before closing you are choosing a broker, and a new one can prepare binders but needs the seller's documents. After closing, you can run a fair selection in your first 90 days. In an asset purchase, new policies are needed at closing either way.

How do I know whether my broker is the problem or the market?

Ask for a written explanation of what changed and which insurers were approached. Specific answers may mean the broker is doing the job in a hard market. Vague answers or no policy review point to a service gap.

References

Just bought a business? Get your insurance reviewed.

Send Morrow the declarations pages, loss runs and key contracts you inherited. Morrow can review them against the business you bought, flag gaps and request quotes where it makes sense. Any new terms depend on carrier underwriting.

Request a review Check a contract

Morrow · 25 New Chardon Street, 4th Floor, Boston, MA 02114

This article is general information, not legal, tax or financial advice, and not a coverage determination. Coverage depends on the actual policy wording, carrier underwriting, your purchase agreement and your contracts. Ask your attorney and accountant about deal and legal questions.

When to Change Insurance Brokers After You Buy a Business