Towing Company Coverage Gaps: Hook, Yard, Spill

The coverage gaps worth checking first when you buy a towing company sit between the policies. A customer's car on your hook may fall between your auto liability and your garagekeepers cover (the cover for customers' cars left in your care), a stored-vehicle yard may be insured on narrow terms, a fuel spill may meet a pollution exclusion, and state minimums may sit far below a bad highway loss. You find each one by reading the forms, not the declarations page. This guide is for buyers of towing and recovery companies who want to know what to ask before a loss asks for them.

The short answer

A key gap risk is the handoff between auto, on-hook, garagekeepers and premises cover. Each form can exclude something the next is supposed to pick up.
Yard cover can differ sharply in how it pays, which causes of loss it names, how much it pays per vehicle and what it excludes, such as theft by your own employees.
Fuel from a wreck raises a pollution wording question. Business income pays for covered physical loss, not for losing a rotation spot or a motor club account.
Do not assume insurance pays refunds or fines from a wrongful tow ruling. Ask the broker in writing.
Most gaps have a fix: an endorsement, a higher limit, a separate policy or a changed practice. A few are business decisions to price into your model.

Which coverage gaps do new towing company owners find?

Whether a fix is available, and at what price, depends on carrier underwriting. For the core policies, see the insurance guide for new towing company owners. This article stays on the gaps.

Towing company coverage gaps, how to spot them and what to ask for
Gap	How to spot it	What to ask for
Vehicle on the hook with no clear cover (a strap fails while a customer's car is moved)	Auto liability excludes property in your care, and garagekeepers speaks to garage operations	Ask for on-hook cover, or written confirmation of how your forms respond
Yard cover that is too thin (hail, fire or theft hits many stored vehicles at once)	Compare the limit, deductible and covered causes of loss with your peak count	Resize the limit, and ask about a direct form
Employee theft of a stored vehicle (a yard worker sells a vehicle)	Garagekeepers excludes theft or conversion by the insured's employees	Ask whether any crime form reaches customers' vehicles in your care (some insure only your own property), in writing
Cash, cards and release fees (a compromised terminal, or a clerk skimming cash at release)	Crime wording (discovery versus loss sustained, social engineering sublimits) and whether cyber is claims made	Size crime and cyber limits to a busy month of fees and cash. See commercial crime insurance
Spill from a wreck (diesel reaches a road or drain)	The auto pollution exclusion can reach pollutants in property being towed	Ask about broadened pollution endorsements or a separate policy
Liability limits at the floor (a highway crash or multi-vehicle recovery)	Compare each truck's limit with what customers and lenders ask	Price umbrella or excess liability
Outdoor yard property (fencing, lighting, gates, vehicles in the open)	Read how the property form treats outdoor property	Get a written answer, and an endorsement if needed
Wrongful tow or overcharge disputes (a refund or penalty after a hearing)	Do not assume coverage for refunds, fines or penalties	Prevent with signage, tickets and fee records
Overflow operators and the audit (contract drivers paid without their own comp)	Audit rules can treat their pay as yours	Collect certificates, or ask counsel whether they belong on payroll

How do you spot a gap in on-hook and yard cover?

Ask for the full forms and read the insuring agreement, the exclusions and the valuation. The exclusions that matter most are laid out in the insurance guide. Neither the auto form nor the garagekeepers endorsement mentions the hook, so get your carrier's answer for a vehicle on your truck in writing.

Then check how the policy pays. A legal liability form pays only when you are legally responsible. A direct form pays regardless of fault and can be written primary or excess. The causes of loss matter too. In the standard Insurance Services Office (ISO) garagekeepers endorsement they are elected separately (comprehensive, specified causes or collision), and its specified causes are fire, lightning, explosion, theft, mischief and vandalism, not hail. Carrier forms differ. See garage and garagekeepers coverage.

A hypothetical example. Hail damages dozens of cars in a storage yard, and the same month thieves strip parts from a row of others. The yard holds 60 vehicles worth about $12,000 each, and the garagekeepers limit is $250,000 with a $1,000 deductible per vehicle. If a single event damaged every car, that is $720,000 of exposure against a $250,000 limit, before any deductible. Separate events, such as hail and later thefts, may each be measured against the per-location limit, depending on the form. Three choices decide what is paid: legal liability or direct basis, which causes of loss were elected (a direct form written on specified causes would not pay hail damage), and how the deductible and per-location limit apply to one event. If a yard worker was behind some thefts, that part may be a crime question, and whether crime cover reaches a customer's vehicle depends on the form. The fix is the right form, sized to your peak count.

Why do state minimums not protect you from a large loss?

Floors set a minimum for the permit. They are not a measure of what a rollover on a busy highway or a multi-vehicle pileup can cost. Texas, for example, sets per-truck liability floors of $300,000 to $500,000. This guide quotes no typical umbrella limit or loss size for towing. Compare three numbers per truck: the state or agency floor, what each contract asks, and what your lender and investors expect.

An umbrella or excess policy adds limits above the underlying liability policies. It usually sits over the auto, general liability and employers liability policies in its schedule, and usually not over professional, cyber, directors and officers or employment practices policies. Whether it follows the underlying exclusions, including property in your care, custody or control, depends on its own wording, so ask the broker in writing and do not assume it fills that gap. See the new owner review of umbrella and excess liability.

What about spills, wrongful tows and repossession claims?

Spills. The standard ISO auto pollution exclusion reaches pollutants contained in property being towed or handled for movement onto the covered auto, with an exception for fluids needed for the covered auto's own functioning. Whether a diesel leak from a wrecked van falls inside it can turn on timing (at the scene before hook-up or after loading) and on the exact wording, and the form has separate exceptions for some upset or overturn accidents away from your premises. Broadened pollution endorsements and separate policies exist, but terms and availability for towing risks vary by carrier. Ask the broker, in writing, what each would pay for a recovery spill and a yard spill, and what it excludes. See new owner review of pollution liability.

Wrongful tow, overcharge and repossession disputes. In Texas, a vehicle owner who believes a vehicle was wrongfully towed, stored or booted, or overcharged, can ask for a justice court hearing, and the regulator lists overcharging a nonconsent tow above the legal fee as a violation. Refunds, fines and penalties are generally not what insurance pays. Do not assume any policy responds to a wrongful tow claim, and ask your broker in writing whether one does. Signage, complete tow tickets and a fee schedule that matches the legal caps are the real control. Repossession clients may also ask you to indemnify them in writing, so have your attorney read that clause and your broker compare it with the policies.

Where do property and income gaps hide in a tow yard?

A yard is mostly open ground, and property forms are written around buildings. On the standard ISO building and personal property form (2012 edition), outdoor fences are covered only through a small extension for a short list of causes: fire, lightning, explosion, riot or civil commotion and aircraft. Vehicles licensed for public roads are not covered property at all, so customers' cars and your trucks need their own cover. Carrier forms differ, so check yours. Valuation matters too: the standard form values property at actual cash value unless replacement cost is shown. See actual cash value versus replacement cost.

A wrecker body, winch, dollies and jacks may be insured with the truck or on a separate equipment form. Ask where each sits and confirm that the lender's loss payable wording covers the financed items.

Business income cover is the other quiet gap. The standard ISO form pays the actual loss of business income from a suspension caused by direct physical loss to property at your premises, after a 72-hour waiting period. It does not pay because you lost a police rotation slot or a motor club account. If one stream is a large share of revenue, that risk is a business decision, not an insurance one. See business interruption insurance.

Which gaps come from the deal itself?

Some gaps come from the purchase itself, not the business: policies that still name the seller, a license or insurance filing that must follow the new licensed entity, and uninsured overflow operators who can land in a workers' comp audit at your class and mod. On the license, Texas says a tow license is not transferable, and its regulator generally requires an original application on a change in ownership, with a limited online update for an existing limited liability company (LLC) or corporation whose federal employer tax ID does not change. How that applies to your deal is a question for counsel. The insurance guide, the contracts, licenses and bonds guide and the workers' comp guide for towing companies own those topics.

How should you decide which gaps to fix first?

You will not close every gap on day one, and some are better priced as a retained risk. A practical order:

Any gap that can stop the company from operating, such as a filing or license insurance mismatch.
Any gap on a loss that could exceed your cash, such as yard cover below your peak count or liability at the floor with no umbrella. A loss above your limits is a debt-service problem and an investor update, so size these first.
Any gap a contract or lender can enforce, such as additional insured wording the policy lacks.
Everything else, priced and scheduled for renewal.

Ask your broker for a written gap list with a recommended action and sequence. See also was the seller underinsured and exclusions that quietly kill coverage. Morrow can review inherited policies and flag gaps, and any new terms depend on carrier underwriting.

Keep reading

Frequently asked questions

Which coverage gap should I check first?

Start with the customer's vehicle on the hook, because auto liability and garagekeepers wording may not clearly respond. This guide does not rank gaps by how often they occur. Then check the yard, pollution and limits.

Does garagekeepers cover a car while it is being towed?

It depends on the wording. The standard ISO garagekeepers endorsement describes a customer's auto in garage operations such as parking or storing it, and does not mention towing. Ask your carrier in writing how your form treats a vehicle on your truck.

Will insurance pay a refund if a tow is ruled wrongful?

Do not assume so. Refunds, fines and penalties are generally not what insurance pays, and a towing-specific professional liability policy cannot be assumed to exist. Ask your broker to confirm in writing what your policies say.

Is a spill from a towed wreck covered by auto liability?

Not necessarily. The standard ISO auto pollution exclusion reaches pollutants in property being towed or handled, with an exception for fluids needed for the covered auto's own functioning, and the result can turn on timing and wording. Ask about broadened pollution cover or a separate policy.

Does business income insurance cover losing a rotation spot or a motor club account?

Generally no. Business income cover responds to direct physical loss to covered property, with a waiting period. Losing a contract or a customer is a business risk, not a covered cause of loss on the standard form.

References

Just bought a business? Get your insurance reviewed.

Send Morrow the declarations pages, loss runs and key contracts you inherited. Morrow can review them against the business you bought, flag gaps and request quotes where it makes sense. Any new terms depend on carrier underwriting.

Request a review Check a contract

Morrow · 25 New Chardon Street, 4th Floor, Boston, MA 02114

This article is general information, not legal, tax or financial advice, and not a coverage determination. Coverage depends on the actual policy wording, carrier underwriting, your purchase agreement and your contracts. Ask your attorney and accountant about deal and legal questions.

Coverage Gaps New Towing Company Owners Find (and Fix)