If the seller carried too little insurance, its earnings before interest, taxes, depreciation and amortization (EBITDA) look higher than they will be under you. The right insurance is a real operating cost, and you are the one who will pay it. Price the program the business actually needs, subtract the extra premium and any extra risk you will keep from run-rate EBITDA, and use that restated number in your model, your lender's debt service math and, if you have not closed, the price conversation. This guide is for buyers who suspect a low insurance bill flattered the numbers they paid for.
The short answer
- Insurance is an operating expense. If the seller underspent on it, every dollar of missing premium shows up as EBITDA that will not last.
- Estimate the right premium from quotes or broker indications for the program you will carry, not from the seller's expense line.
- Split the gap into recurring items (a higher premium every year) and one-time items (a tail policy, a past audit bill, an uninsured loss). Only recurring items change run-rate EBITDA.
- Before closing, share the evidence with your quality of earnings provider and deal counsel. After closing, rebase the budget, tell the board and lender, and phase the fixes.
Why does an underinsured seller overstate EBITDA?
A buyer pays for earnings that will continue, and insurance is a cost of producing them, like rent or payroll. When a seller carries limits that are too low, skips lines of coverage the business clearly needs, or insures property at values set years ago, the premium is lower than it should be. The difference flows straight to EBITDA.
This is usually not a scheme. Owner-operators often choose to carry risk personally: they have no lender watching, years without claims and enough personal wealth to absorb a bad year. That can be reasonable for them, and the seller's broker may have done exactly what was asked. It rarely fits a buyer carrying acquisition debt, a personal guaranty and outside investors. The cost of that risk did not disappear; it was never booked.
The effect is multiplied. If you price a business on a multiple of EBITDA, each recurring dollar of missing premium is worth several dollars of purchase price. Accounting firms that perform quality of earnings (QoE) reviews list normalizing insurance cost among typical adjustments. Whether yours makes it depends on the engagement, so ask.
Property insured at stale values carries a second cost. Many commercial property policies have a coinsurance clause that cuts the claim payment, even on a partial loss, when the insured value falls below a set percentage of the property's value at the time of loss (replacement cost or actual cash value, depending on the policy). That is a reason to fix values right away rather than wait for renewal; check the policy wording and see coinsurance.
If you are still working out whether the seller was underinsured at all, start with the signs of an underinsured seller. This article picks up once you think the answer is yes and you need a number.
How do you estimate the premium the business should be paying?
The seller's insurance expense shows what was paid, not what the business needs. Build the number from the program you intend to carry.
- List the exposures: employees, vehicles, property, products, advice, data, money handling and contracts.
- Set target limits and terms. Start with what customer contracts, the lease and your lender require, then add what a worst realistic loss would cost. Use replacement cost for property, not the purchase price allocation, which measures something else.
- Get market pricing. Ask a broker for indications or quotes on that program using current payroll, revenue, vehicle and property figures. A quote is not coverage and can change in underwriting, but it beats guessing.
- Add what you will now keep. If the right program carries higher deductibles than the seller had, or you plan to self-insure a risk, estimate the losses you will pay yourself from the loss runs.
- Compare line by line with the seller's actual premiums, not the ledger total, which may include personal policies.
| Input | Where it comes from | What to watch |
|---|---|---|
| Exposure figures | Payroll reports, revenue, vehicle list, property schedule | Seller policies rated on stale figures understate premium and can trigger audit bills |
| Required limits | Customer contracts, lease, loan agreement | Requirements you cannot meet can cost revenue, not only premium |
| Property values | Replacement cost estimate or appraisal | Purchase price and book value are not insurable value |
| Claims history | Loss runs (the carriers' claim reports) for three to five years | Open claims and reserves affect how carriers price the account |
| Market pricing | Broker indications or quotes | Indications are estimates; terms depend on underwriting |
How do you restate EBITDA for the insurance gap?
Once you have the go-forward cost, the restatement is simple arithmetic. Treat it as a normalizing or pro forma adjustment: restate earnings as if the business had carried the right program all along.
A hypothetical example. A services business reports EBITDA of $2,000,000 before any add-backs. The seller paid $60,000 a year in business insurance premium. Separately, the business paid $5,000 a year for the seller's personal umbrella, booked as insurance expense, which stops at closing. Quotes for a program that meets the lease, the lender and the main customer contracts come to $110,000. The new program uses higher deductibles, and the loss runs suggest the business will pay about $10,000 a year of small losses itself.
| Item | Amount |
|---|---|
| Reported EBITDA | $2,000,000 |
| Less: premium increase for the right program ($110,000 minus $60,000) | ($50,000) |
| Less: expected losses kept under higher deductibles | ($10,000) |
| Add back: seller's personal policy paid by the business | $5,000 |
| Restated EBITDA | $1,945,000 |
| Effect on value at an illustrative 5x multiple | $275,000 lower |
The shape is common: a modest premium gap becomes a meaningful valuation gap. This is the mirror image of the saving in insurance savings as an EBITDA lever: the multiple works in both directions. The restated figure also belongs in your debt service math. Lenders size loans on cash flow, and the Small Business Administration (SBA) sets a specific rule for larger deals. Under its standard operating procedure (SOP) 50 10 8.1, a 7(a) change of ownership loan (an Initial Acquisition or Business Expansion loan) with a business purchase price of $3 million or more requires a QoE report. The lender must use the report's findings when it calculates debt service coverage. A premium increase discovered after closing comes straight out of the cushion your lender tested.
Which insurance adjustments are recurring and which are one-time?
Only recurring costs change run-rate EBITDA. One-time costs matter to cash and to the deal, but they should not be multiplied. Keep them separate in the model.
| Item | Recurring or one-time | Usual treatment |
|---|---|---|
| Higher limits or added lines of coverage | Recurring | Reduces run-rate EBITDA |
| Moving property to replacement cost or current values | Recurring | Reduces run-rate EBITDA |
| Expected small losses under higher deductibles | Recurring | Reduces run-rate EBITDA; check the estimate against loss history |
| Seller's personal policies paid by the business | Recurring, but ending | Usually added back |
| Tail coverage on the seller's claims-made policies | One-time | Cash item; who pays is a deal term |
| Workers' compensation audit balance for pre-closing payroll | One-time | Cash item; who owes it depends on deal structure and the purchase agreement |
| A past uninsured loss | One-time | QoE practice often adds it back, but ask whether the same type of loss could recur |
| A general market price increase | Recurring | Not underinsurance; model it separately as a renewal assumption |
Two rows deserve care. An uninsured loss added back as one-time still tells you something: the coverage gap that caused it may still be there. And a rising market is a budgeting question, covered in budgeting insurance in your acquisition model. Ask your accountant how each item should be presented in your financial statements.
How can you use the gap before closing?
If you find underinsurance before you sign, you have options, and all of them work better with evidence.
- Bring it to the QoE provider. Share the quotes and the contract and lender requirements so the provider can consider a normalizing or pro forma adjustment. See insurance in your quality of earnings review.
- Raise it in price discussions. A restated EBITDA backed by real quotes is a concrete basis for discussion; how hard to push is a judgment for you and your advisors.
- Ask the seller to fix specific items. Some gaps are cleaner to solve before closing, such as buying tail coverage on claims-made policies or reporting known circumstances to the current carriers.
- Use deal protections. Indemnities, escrows and holdbacks are legal and negotiated terms. Deal counsel should advise on whether and how to use them; see seller indemnities vs insurance.
- Budget it. Sometimes the answer is to accept the price and plan for the higher cost from day one.
Keep it factual. You are not accusing the seller or the seller's broker; you are showing that the business costs more to insure under a leveraged owner.
What if you find the gap after closing?
Most new owners find underinsurance in the first few months. The price is set, so the job is managing the impact.
- Rebase the budget. Replace the seller's insurance line with the go-forward cost and update the forecast you share with your board.
- Check your covenants. Run the restated EBITDA through your debt service and leverage covenants. If the cushion is thin, tell your lender early.
- Fix the biggest exposures first, in the order set out in what to do about an underinsured seller.
- Choose the timing. Some fixes can be added mid-term by endorsement; others are better done at renewal. See when to remarket.
- Look for offsets. Correcting class codes, removing vehicles you no longer have and right-sizing deductibles can recover part of the increase. See where insurance savings come from.
- Report it plainly to investors: show reported and restated EBITDA side by side, the one-time costs separately, and the offsets you expect.
A Morrow review can request quotes on the right program for the business you bought and show the line-by-line gap against what the seller carried, so the number in your model rests on quotes rather than guesses. Any new terms depend on carrier underwriting.
Keep reading
- Was the Seller Underinsured? How to Tell and What It Costs You
- Insurance in Your Quality of Earnings Review: What to Adjust and Ask
- Budgeting Insurance in Your Acquisition Model
- Insurance Savings as an EBITDA Lever: What a Lower Premium Is Worth
- Seller Indemnities vs Insurance: What They Are Really Worth
- All guides for new business owners
Frequently asked questions
Should a quality of earnings report adjust EBITDA for an underinsured seller?
It can, but not every report does. Some providers normalize insurance cost or make pro forma adjustments for costs the business will carry going forward. Give your provider quotes and requirements as evidence, and ask whether insurance is in scope.
How do I know what the right premium is before I own the business?
Ask a broker for indications or quotes on the program you intend to carry, using the business's current payroll, revenue, vehicles and property values. A quote is not bound coverage and can change in underwriting, but it beats the seller's expense line.
Is a higher insurance cost a reason to renegotiate the price?
It can be, if it is backed by quotes and real requirements. Whether and how to renegotiate is a business and legal judgment for you and your deal counsel.
Does a past uninsured loss lower true EBITDA?
Diligence providers often add a one-time uninsured loss back to adjusted EBITDA. The bigger question is whether the gap that left it uninsured still exists. If it does, close it and include that cost in your go-forward numbers.
I already closed. Is it too late to do anything?
No. Rebase your budget, tell your lender and board early, fix the largest exposures first and look for offsetting savings. Any rights against the seller under the purchase agreement are a question for your deal counsel.
References
- The Bonadio Group: What to Expect in a Quality of Earnings Analysis
- Pease Bell CPAs: Quality of Earnings Adjustments, How They Change EBITDA in a Deal
- SBA: SOP 50 10 8.1, Lender and Development Company Loan Programs
Just bought a business? Get your insurance reviewed.
Send Morrow the declarations pages, loss runs and key contracts you inherited. Morrow can review them against the business you bought, flag gaps and request quotes where it makes sense. Any new terms depend on carrier underwriting.
Morrow · 25 New Chardon Street, 4th Floor, Boston, MA 02114
This article is general information, not legal, tax or financial advice, and not a coverage determination. Coverage depends on the actual policy wording, carrier underwriting, your purchase agreement and your contracts. Ask your attorney and accountant about deal and legal questions.