Marketing Agency Insurance Gaps After You Buy

The coverage gaps that surprise a new owner of a marketing agency are often not missing policies. They are exclusions (things a policy says it will not pay for) in policies the agency already has, and they sit where standard coverage stops at the edge of the agency's own work: copyright and advertising claims, text, email and website tracking claims, client contract promises, payment fraud and client property. A new owner can spot them by reading the exclusions, the client contracts and the last few campaigns side by side. This guide is for the buyer of an advertising, digital, public relations or media buying agency who already knows the core policies. The core stack is in the first guide in this set.

The short answer

Read the forms before you buy anything: exclusions, sublimits (lower caps on certain claims) and definitions first.
The standard general liability form removes personal and advertising injury coverage for an insured whose business is advertising and excludes claims tied to texting, calling and email laws. Ask which other policy answers those claims, in writing.
Contract indemnities, client-owned property and social engineering losses are three places where a sound looking program can have a hole.
Some gaps are fixed by buying coverage. Others are fixed by process, such as consent records and payment call-backs. A few, like a client leaving, are generally not covered by standard property or liability policies.
A quote or a review request is not coverage. Keep the old policies running until new terms are confirmed in writing.

Which gaps matter most in a marketing agency?

Use this table as a reading list. Each row names the gap, how it tends to show up, how to spot it in your documents and what to ask for. Forms vary, so the policy wording in your file controls.

Coverage gaps to look for in an agency's program
Gap	How it shows up	How to spot it	What to ask for
Ad and copyright claims outside general liability	An unlicensed image, font or music clip in a campaign	The exclusion for an insured in the advertising business	Media liability wording, with the retroactive date confirmed
Text, call and email law claims	A promotional text sent to an old or purchased list	The general liability exclusion for statutes that limit sending material, plus any similar wording in the cyber or media forms	A written answer on which policy responds, if any
Website tracking and privacy claims	A demand letter about analytics or chat tools on a client site	Any statutory or wiretap type exclusion in the cyber and media forms	Counsel's view on the law and the broker's view on the form
Contract indemnities	A client agreement says the agency will indemnify it for intellectual property claims	Contractual liability exclusions in general liability and professional forms	A contract review against the policies before signing renewals. See the contracts, licenses and bonds guide for the clause list
Social engineering losses	A spoofed vendor email changes bank details	A crime policy with computer fraud and funds transfer wording but no social engineering option	The option, or fraudulent impersonation wording, and a limit that fits the largest payment
Client data in your care	Customer lists and ad account access sit in agency cloud accounts	No cyber policy, or notice duties in contracts that the policy does not match	Cyber coverage aligned with contract duties
An umbrella that does not reach	A large umbrella limit looks like protection for everything	Schedule of underlying policies	Higher limits on the professional and cyber policies themselves
Client-owned property	Product samples, props and event inventory the agency holds	Whether the property form covers others' property in your care, to what limit, and away from the office at shoots and events	Written confirmation of that coverage, or a form written for property of others if the volume justifies it. Ask the client whether its own policy covers its goods
Lost fees after a client or key person leaves	The largest client terminates a few months after closing	Business income wording tied to physical loss	No standard property or liability policy responds. Plan for it in the model and the retention plan
Employee-owned cars on client errands	An account manager drives to a shoot	No hired and non-owned auto on the policy	That coverage, usually by endorsement or a separate policy

How does a text blast fall through the cracks?

Messaging claims are the clearest example of a gap hiding between policies. The federal Telephone Consumer Protection Act (TCPA) limits autodialed and prerecorded calls and texts. A person harmed by a violation can sue for the greater of actual loss or $500 per violation, and a court may increase that up to three times for willful or knowing violations. Counted per message, a list of thousands adds up fast. The federal commercial email law lets the Federal Trade Commission (FTC) seek per-email civil penalties, and it says that both the company whose product is promoted and the company that sends the message may be responsible. Hiring an email vendor does not remove that duty.

A hypothetical example. An agency sends a promotional text campaign for a retail client to a purchased list of 20,000 numbers. Several hundred recipients had opted out before. A class action names the client and the agency and alleges consent violations. The agency checks its general liability policy and finds the exclusion for statutes that limit sending material. It then reads its cyber and media forms and finds that neither clearly addresses this claim. Nobody knows which policy, if any, responds, and the question arrives after the complaint, not before.

The same pattern applies to website tracking. California's Invasion of Privacy Act lets an injured person recover the greater of $5,000 per violation or three times actual damages. How the law applies to tracking tools, and which policy might respond, are questions for counsel and for the form wording, not for a summary. Ask the broker to say in writing which policy, if any, was designed for each of these claims.

What about influencer campaigns and reviews?

The FTC's Endorsement Guides say advertisers can be liable for misleading endorsements, and that advertising agencies and public relations firms may be liable for their roles in creating or spreading them, including when they know or should know the content is deceptive. The text turns on role, knowledge and disclosures, so liability is not automatic. FTC guidance also says that handing a program to an outside company does not relieve the advertiser of responsibility, and intermediaries that recruit and pay influencers should have reasonable programs to train and monitor them.

A separate FTC rule bans buying, selling or spreading fake reviews and testimonials when the business knew or should have known they were fake. The insurance question is whether a form covers regulatory inquiries and the costs of responding, and that is form specific. Treat it as an open item to ask about. The better defense is process: written approval of posts, collected disclosures and records of who checked what. Ask the seller for those records before closing and keep them afterward.

Which gaps come from the deal itself?

Some gaps appear only because ownership changed. The standard general liability form can add a newly acquired organization automatically, but only for a limited window (90 days in the standard form), and it excludes advertising offenses committed before the acquisition. It does not apply at all to a limited liability company (LLC), partnership or joint venture, so ask whether the agency is an LLC. It also generally does not apply when the agency keeps its own general liability policy after a stock purchase, and a first-time buyer with no policy of its own has nothing for it to attach to. The practical step is to have the agency named on your policies by endorsement. Wording varies by carrier.

Claims-made policies carry the same deal gap: the new policy's retroactive date decides how much past work it sees. The first guide covers the fix. Old campaigns that are still published may also draw claims later. See adding a newly acquired company to your policies, do your policies still list the seller and exclusions that quietly kill coverage.

One more deal gap sits with people. Freelance designers, writers and developers work through the agency. Whether the agency's workers' compensation audit treats them as employees, and whether any policy responds to a mistake in their work, depends on contracts and wording. The workers' comp guide for marketing agencies covers the audit side.

How do I find these gaps in my own policies?

Get the full policy forms, not only the declarations pages. Endorsements often change the wording that matters. See declarations page vs full policy.
Pull the three largest client contracts. Mark every indemnity, insurance requirement and notice duty, then line them up against the policies.
List the campaign types the agency runs. Mark text or call programs, email, influencers, sweepstakes, tracking tools and events. Each one points to a clause to read.
Ask the broker six written questions. Which policy answers an image claim, a text or email claim, a tracking claim, a regulator letter, a fake invoice and a data breach? Ask for each answer to cite a form.
Read the loss runs. Look for notices of circumstances that were never followed up.
Run a structured review. The step-by-step review guide shows what a reviewer should deliver.

If you want a second reader on the forms, a Morrow review can run these questions against the declarations pages and policy forms you inherited. Any new terms depend on carrier underwriting.

Which gaps can I fix, and which just need a decision?

Sort each gap into one of three buckets.

Buy or reword. Media liability wording, a social engineering option, written confirmation of cover for property of others and non-owned auto. Terms depend on carrier underwriting, and a quote is not coverage until the carrier binds it.
Fix by process. Consent records for texts and email, influencer approvals, bank detail call-backs and license inventories. Controls reduce the chance of a claim, and some policies make coverage depend on them, such as call-back verification for payment changes. Check the wording.
Accept and plan. Lost clients and departed key people. Model them, discuss them with your lender and investors, and keep the retention plan current.

Client indemnities are a contract question first. The contracts, licenses and bonds guide lists the clauses to read before you decide whether to buy more cover or renegotiate.

Known problems are different from unknown ones. Insurance generally helps with unknown liabilities, so a claim the seller already knew about is usually handled by price, a specific indemnity or an escrow. See seller indemnities vs insurance. Cost trade-offs for closing these gaps are in what drives insurance cost for a marketing agency.

Keep reading

Frequently asked questions

Which coverage gap should I check first?

Start with general liability. The standard form removes personal and advertising injury coverage for an insured whose business is advertising, a common assumption worth testing first. Then read the text, email and tracking exclusions and ask which policy answers each, in writing. This order comes from how the standard forms are written, not from claim counts.

Does my cyber policy cover privacy claims from website tracking?

It depends on the form, and some forms may exclude or sublimit statutory privacy and wiretap claims. Ask your broker to point to the exact wording and any sublimit, and ask counsel how the law applies to the tools on your client sites.

Will my umbrella policy raise the limit on a professional claim?

Usually not. A commercial umbrella typically does not sit over professional liability, cyber, directors and officers or employment practices policies. Raise limits on those policies directly if the contracts or the risk call for it.

Is a client contract's indemnity covered by my insurance?

Not automatically. The standard general liability form excludes advertising liability you assume in a contract, except liability you would have had without the contract, and professional forms often have similar wording. Have a broker compare the indemnity with the policy wording before you sign or renew.

Can I rely on the seller's broker to tell me where the gaps are?

The seller's broker may know the account well and may have done a fine job for the previous owner. A new owner has different exposures, so ask the same written questions of any broker and compare the answers.

References

Just bought a business? Get your insurance reviewed.

Send Morrow the declarations pages, loss runs and key contracts you inherited. Morrow can review them against the business you bought, flag gaps and request quotes where it makes sense. Any new terms depend on carrier underwriting.

Request a review Check a contract

Morrow · 25 New Chardon Street, 4th Floor, Boston, MA 02114

This article is general information, not legal, tax or financial advice, and not a coverage determination. Coverage depends on the actual policy wording, carrier underwriting, your purchase agreement and your contracts. Ask your attorney and accountant about deal and legal questions.

Coverage Gaps New Owners of Marketing Agencies Find