How to Reduce Insurance Costs After Buying a Business

The most reliable way to lower insurance costs after you buy a business is to fix the data the premium is built on: payroll, class codes, vehicles and property values. Then give underwriters a clear story about the new owner before you remarket (ask other carriers to quote). Higher deductibles and risk control come after that, and cutting coverage comes last, if at all, because one uninsured loss can cost more than years of premium. This guide is for new owners who want an order of operations rather than a list of tricks.

The short answer

Step 1: clean up the data. Premiums are built on payroll, class codes, vehicle lists, property values and revenue, and inherited data is often out of date.
Step 2: fix the account story. Underwriters price uncertainty, so explain who you are, what the loss history means and what you are changing.
Step 3: remarket at the right time, usually ahead of renewal, with a complete and accurate submission.
Step 4: use deductibles and risk control where your cash flow can carry the risk, and choose payment terms that suit cash flow (they spread cost rather than lower it). Treat cutting coverage as a last resort.

Why is cutting coverage the wrong first move?

It is tempting to look at the premium line, see a policy you do not understand, and drop it. After an acquisition that is usually backwards, for three reasons.

You are leveraged. An uninsured loss comes straight out of cash flow you need for debt service. A premium saving of a few thousand dollars a year is small next to a single claim you now pay yourself.
Someone may require it. Lenders, landlords and customers often require specific coverages and limits. Dropping one can put you in breach of a loan agreement or a contract.
Some coverage is hard to restart. On claims-made policies such as professional liability or employment practices, letting coverage lapse and buying it again later can reset the retroactive date (the earliest date of acts the policy covers), leaving past work uncovered.

The bigger savings usually come from paying the right price for the right coverage. Inherited programs are often priced on information that has not kept up with the business, and fixing that does not cost you any protection. Corrections can move the price either way: understated payroll or property values will raise it, but paying the right amount now beats a surprise at audit or after a claim. When savings do come, they flow straight to earnings before interest, taxes, depreciation and amortization (EBITDA); see how insurance savings move EBITDA.

In what order should you tackle insurance costs?

Work in four phases. Each one makes the next one work better: clean data makes the account story credible, and a credible story gets better results when you remarket.

Phase	When	What you do	Go deeper
1. Clean the data	First 30 to 90 days	Check payroll estimates, class codes, the experience mod (a multiplier that raises or lowers workers' comp premium based on past claims), vehicles, equipment, property values, revenue and subcontractor certificates	Class code corrections, mod errors, remove what you no longer have
2. Fix the account story	Before you remarket	Write a short new-owner summary, explain past losses, close old open claims, document safety and controls	What underwriters want, close old claims
3. Remarket	Usually 90 to 120 days before renewal	Send a complete submission to carriers that want your type of business	How to remarket, mid-term or renewal
4. Deductibles, structure and risk control	At renewal and ongoing	Set deductibles you can carry, package where it fits, choose payment terms, invest in loss control	Raising deductibles, packaging policies, safety programs

For the full menu of tactics in one place, see 12 ways to lower premium without cutting coverage.

Is the data behind your premium correct?

Most commercial premiums are a rate multiplied by an exposure: payroll, revenue, vehicles, square footage or property values. If the exposure or the classification is wrong, the premium is wrong, and an owner who ran the business for twenty years may not have updated it in a long time.

Workers' compensation

Under the standard National Council on Compensation Insurance (NCCI) policy and rating approach, premium is generally a rate per $100 of payroll for each class code, times the payroll in that class, with the experience mod applied. The premium you pay up front is an estimate; an audit after the policy ends sets the final premium from actual payroll and the correct class codes. Check three things:

Class codes. Codes classify the business, not each employee's job title, and a few standard exceptions such as clerical office work apply only when the duties truly fit. A wrong governing code (the main code that describes the business) can be an expensive mistake; see workers' comp class codes. California, Pennsylvania and Delaware use their own classification systems, and the state funds in Ohio, Washington, North Dakota and Wyoming set their own rules, so check the state's system before comparing codes.
Payroll splits. Where the rules allow one employee's pay to be split between codes, the payroll records must show actual hours and pay in each. Estimates and percentage splits are generally not accepted, and the pay can default to the highest rated code.
Subcontractors. Pay to subcontractors who cannot show they had their own workers' comp can be added to your premium at audit. Collect certificates before work starts. A certificate is evidence, not proof: the audit test is whether the subcontractor actually had workers' comp in force, and state law on statutory employers (when your company is treated as the employer of a subcontractor's workers) controls.

Lowering the payroll estimate below what you expect to pay does not save money. It only moves the cost into an audit bill; see payroll estimates and surprise audit bills.

Auto, property and liability

Vehicles and drivers. Sold or retired vehicles still on the schedule, and drivers who have left, inflate auto premium.
Property values. Values can be too high (equipment long gone) or too low. Too low is not a saving: if limits fall below the coinsurance requirement, a claim can be cut proportionally. The purchase price is not the insurable value.
Revenue and operations. General liability is often rated on revenue or payroll and on how the operations are described. An outdated description can put you in a higher-rated class.
Overlap. Owner-run companies sometimes carry two policies covering the same thing; see duplicate and overlapping coverage.

What story does your account tell an underwriter?

To an underwriter, a new owner is an unknown. Unknowns get priced cautiously. Your job is to replace guesswork with facts. A good new-owner submission usually includes:

Your background and the management team, and who runs operations day to day.
What stays the same (people, services, customers) and what you plan to change.
A plain explanation of each significant past loss and what was done to prevent a repeat.
Status of open claims, and steps to close the ones that are effectively resolved.
Safety, hiring and driver standards, and how you check subcontractors' insurance.
Controls for cyber and payment fraud, such as multifactor authentication and call-back checks on payment changes.

In states that follow NCCI rules, the seller's claims history usually transfers to you, even in an asset purchase into a new company. So in most deals you cannot leave a poor mod behind. Excluding the seller's experience is rare: it needs a near-complete change of owners, operations and hazards, and the rating organization decides. What you can do is show underwriters that the risks behind it are being managed, which can help pricing now; the mod itself improves only as cleaner years replace older ones in the rating period. See what underwriters want to see from a new owner and contractual risk transfer for subcontractors.

When should you shop your insurance to other carriers?

Remarketing means asking other carriers to quote. Done well, it can improve price, terms or both. Done in a rush, it can create gaps.

Timing. Renewal is usually the cleanest moment. Cancelling mid-term is possible, but when the insured cancels, the refund may be less than pro rata (a short-rate penalty), depending on the policy, the carrier's filings and state law. Excess and surplus lines policies often have a minimum earned premium and fully earned fees, so check the cancellation terms before you plan a mid-term switch.
One broker per carrier. Carriers generally will not quote the same account through two brokers at once, so decide who represents you before quotes go out. A broker of record letter can move an existing policy to a new broker, usually without changing its coverage, though some carriers cancel and rewrite the policy when the change takes effect; each carrier sets its own waiting period and process.
The right market. Some inherited accounts sit with excess and surplus lines carriers (specialty insurers that take risks standard carriers decline) because of past losses or an unusual operation. Once the data and story are cleaned up, a standard carrier may be an option.
No gap at the switch. A quote is not coverage. Do not cancel the old policy until the new one is bound and the dates line up.

More in broker of record letters and admitted vs excess and surplus lines.

When do higher deductibles and risk control pay off?

A higher deductible trades a lower premium for more risk you carry yourself. It makes sense when the premium credit is large compared with the extra money you would pay per claim, and when your cash and covenants can absorb that extra amount in a bad year.

A hypothetical example. A carrier offers to cut a property premium by $3,000 a year if the deductible rises from $5,000 to $25,000. Each claim of $25,000 or more would now cost the company $20,000 more, and smaller claims somewhat less. If the business has a property claim less often than once every six or seven years ($20,000 divided by $3,000), the higher deductible comes out ahead over time. If it had two claims last year, or if a $25,000 hit would strain its covenant headroom, it probably does not. The numbers here are illustrative; run the same math on your own quotes. The full method, line by line from the loss runs with a stress test for a bad year, is in raising deductibles after an acquisition.

Other levers in this phase:

Risk control that reduces claims, such as fleet telematics and driver standards, return-to-work programs and cyber controls.
Payment terms such as pay-as-you-go workers' comp, which spreads cost but keeps the audit. Financing a premium also spreads cost, but it carries interest and cancellation terms; see premium financing for new owners.
Packaging several coverages into one policy where the business is eligible.

How do you know your insurance costs really went down?

Measure insurance the way you measure any other cost line, so you can tell real savings from changes in the business. A lower bill is not always a saving, and a higher one is not always a price increase.

Premium per unit of exposure, for example workers' comp cost per $100 of payroll or auto cost per vehicle. If payroll grew faster than premium, your rate went down even though the bill went up.
Retained losses: deductibles paid and uninsured claims. A lower premium that comes with bigger deductible payments may not be a saving at all.
Audit adjustments: a low upfront premium that turns into a large audit bill was never a saving.
Total cost of risk: premium plus retained losses plus the cost of safety and claims programs, tracked year over year.

Be careful with forecasts. No carrier promises next year's price, and a single large claim can change the picture. Count savings once they are achieved, not as targets. For a format your lender and board can read, see how to report on insurance to your investors and board and total cost of risk for small holding companies. If you would like a second set of eyes, Morrow can review the program you inherited and flag where the data or structure looks off.

Keep reading

Frequently asked questions

How soon after closing can I lower my insurance costs?

Data fixes, such as removing sold vehicles or correcting a payroll estimate, can often be made by endorsement during the policy term. Bigger changes, like moving carriers or restructuring the program, usually work best at renewal, with the preparation starting 90 to 120 days before.

Will switching to a new carrier save money right away?

Not necessarily. A new carrier prices the same data and loss history, and no carrier promises a lower price. Switching tends to help most after you have corrected the data and can explain the account clearly.

Should I lower my payroll estimate to reduce the workers' comp deposit?

Only if the lower number is accurate. The upfront premium is an estimate, and the audit after the policy ends sets the final premium from actual payroll. An estimate that is too low usually just turns into an audit bill.

Can I drop coverages the seller carried that I do not think I need?

Check first whether a lender, landlord or customer contract requires them, and whether a claims-made policy would lose its retroactive date if it lapses. If neither applies and the exposure truly no longer exists, removing it can make sense, but for a claims-made policy ask about a tail (an extended reporting period) first, because claims about past work can arrive years later.

Does buying through a new LLC give me a fresh experience mod?

Usually not. In states that use NCCI rules, an asset purchase where you take over the operations is still an ownership change, and the seller's experience generally transfers to your company. Several states with their own rating bureaus, including California, New York, Minnesota and Pennsylvania, have parallel rules, the details differ by state, and the rating organization decides each case.

References

Just bought a business? Get your insurance reviewed.

Send Morrow the declarations pages, loss runs and key contracts you inherited. Morrow can review them against the business you bought, flag gaps and request quotes where it makes sense. Any new terms depend on carrier underwriting.

Request a review Check a contract

Morrow · 25 New Chardon Street, 4th Floor, Boston, MA 02114

This article is general information, not legal, tax or financial advice, and not a coverage determination. Coverage depends on the actual policy wording, carrier underwriting, your purchase agreement and your contracts. Ask your attorney and accountant about deal and legal questions.

How to Reduce Insurance Costs After You Buy a Business