Customer Contracts Require Insurance You Lack?

If the business signed customer contracts that require insurance it does not carry, it may be out of compliance with those contracts today. The fix is to find each gap, then change the policy or renegotiate the requirement before a claim tests it. Many new owners find out by accident: a customer asks for a fresh certificate after closing, a vendor portal rejects one, or a claim arrives and the promised endorsement is not on the policy. This guide is for buyers who suspect the seller signed contracts that the inherited insurance does not back up.

The short answer

Owner-run businesses often sign customer contracts without matching the insurance exhibit to the policies, so gaps build up over years.
The usual gaps are limits, additional insured status, primary and noncontributory wording, waiver of subrogation, and professional or cyber coverage the business never bought.
A gap can mean breach of contract, withheld payments, a lost customer, or paying yourself for a loss the required insurance would have covered.
Gaps usually close by endorsement, a higher umbrella limit, a new line of coverage, or a negotiated change to the contract, subject to carrier underwriting.
Start with the contracts that drive the most revenue and the most risk.

How do new owners find out the business is out of compliance?

Rarely by reading the contracts first. More often, something outside the business forces the question within the first few months:

The customer is asked to consent to assignment. In an asset deal, contracts with an anti-assignment clause often need the customer's consent to move to your new entity, and many customers use that moment to check your insurance against their current template. Deal counsel can confirm which contracts needed consent.
A customer asks for a new certificate because the insured name or broker changed at closing, and their risk team reads it against the contract for the first time in years.
A vendor compliance portal flags you as noncompliant when the renewal certificate is uploaded. See certificates for vendor compliance portals.
A master service agreement comes up for renewal and the customer's new template has higher limits or new coverage lines.
A claim is tendered. A customer is sued over something you did and asks your carrier to defend them as an additional insured. The carrier checks the policy and the endorsement is not there.
Lender or investor diligence asks for a summary of material contracts and their insurance terms.

The last two are the expensive ways to learn. The goal of this guide is to find the gaps before either happens. The step-by-step method for reviewing contracts is in how to check your customer contracts against your policies.

Why would the seller have signed requirements the business did not meet?

Usually for ordinary reasons. In an owner-run company, the owner signs the customer's paper to win the work, and the insurance exhibit is page 14 of a 20-page agreement. Larger customers update their templates every few years, so requirements creep upward while the policy stays the same. The business grows into new services, new customers and new states, and nobody sends the new contracts to the broker.

The seller's broker may have done a good job with what it was shown. A broker can only match policies to contracts it actually receives. Treat any gap as a fit question for the business you now own, not as a verdict on anyone's past work.

Certificates also hide the problem. A certificate of insurance is a summary, not the policy, and a box marked for additional insured on a certificate does not create that coverage. State law backs this up in some places; New York Insurance Law section 502, for example, bars certificates from changing the coverage in the policy. A customer may have accepted the seller's certificates for years without anyone checking the endorsements behind them. See why a certificate is not coverage.

Which contract requirements are most often missing?

Common contract requirements and how inherited policies fall short
Requirement	What the contract asks for	How the policy often falls short
Liability limits	A set amount per occurrence and in aggregate, sometimes with an umbrella on top	Primary limit or umbrella below the contract amount, or an umbrella that does not follow the required endorsements
Additional insured	The customer added to your general liability (and often auto and umbrella), for ongoing and completed work	No endorsement, a scheduled endorsement that does not list this customer, or ongoing work only
Primary and noncontributory	Your policy pays before the customer's own insurance and does not ask it to share	Standard other insurance wording without the endorsement
Waiver of subrogation	Your carrier gives up its right to recover from the customer after paying a loss	Waiver on general liability but not on workers' compensation or auto, or none at all
Professional liability	Errors and omissions coverage for advice, design, software or other professional services	Not purchased, because the business saw itself as a trade, not a profession
Cyber liability	Coverage for data breaches and network security failures when you access customer systems or data	Not purchased, or limits far below the contract
Completed operations duration	Additional insured status for a set number of years after the job ends	No completed operations endorsement, or a term that ends earlier
Notice of cancellation	Advance notice to the customer if coverage is canceled	No endorsement providing notice to third parties

A workers' compensation waiver is its own endorsement, often with an added charge, and the rules vary by state. Ask your broker whether it can be granted in each state where you work before you agree to it.

For plain-English explanations of the three most common asks, see additional insured, waiver of subrogation and primary noncontributory.

What is the real risk if a contract requires coverage I do not have?

The insurance requirement is a promise in the contract. If the business does not keep it, the consequences depend on the contract wording and the governing law, so talk to your attorney about any specific contract. In general terms, the risks look like this:

You may end up paying the loss yourself. If the customer would have been covered as an additional insured and is not, it may look to the business for what the insurance would have paid, on top of any indemnity promise in the contract.
Payments can be held. Many customers will not pay invoices or release retainage while a vendor is noncompliant.
The customer may be able to terminate or stop sending work. For a business where the top five customers drive most of the earnings before interest, taxes, depreciation and amortization (EBITDA), losing one is a debt service problem.
Indemnity can outrun your coverage. Many contracts make you hold the customer harmless for broad categories of loss. Liability policies often cover some liability assumed under contract, but not every promise in every indemnity clause, so the gap can be larger than the insurance exhibit suggests.

If the gap existed before closing, ask your attorney whether the purchase agreement's representations or indemnity give you any recourse against the seller. See seller indemnities vs insurance.

How do I close the gap?

There are four tools, and most businesses use all of them across different contracts:

Endorse the policy. Many carriers offer blanket endorsements that grant additional insured status, primary and noncontributory wording and waivers of subrogation to anyone you agreed in a written contract to cover. One blanket endorsement can fix dozens of contracts at once, subject to the carrier's underwriting and any added premium. Read the blanket wording itself: many forms require the contract to be signed before a loss, limit coverage to what the contract requires, and may cover ongoing work only unless completed operations is added. See blanket vs scheduled additional insured.
Raise limits with an umbrella. A commercial umbrella is often the practical way to meet higher limits, as long as its terms extend to the additional insureds and the contract accepts an umbrella toward the total.
Add the missing line. If customers require professional liability or cyber liability, request quotes. A quote is not coverage; the requirement is met only once the carrier binds the policy and you have the declarations page.
Negotiate the contract. Insurance exhibits are often negotiable, especially at renewal or when the customer wants to keep a reliable vendor. Ask for limits that match the real risk, an umbrella credit, or a written waiver of a requirement you cannot reasonably meet. Get any change in writing.

Do not paper over a gap with a certificate that says more than the policy does. Fix the policy, then issue the certificate. See when requirements exceed your policy.

Which gaps should I fix first?

Not every gap is equally urgent. Work them in this order:

Active work with injury or property damage exposure: missing additional insured, primary and noncontributory or waiver endorsements on jobs underway today.
Your largest customers: any gap that could stop payments or cost a top-five account.
Contracts renewing soon: your best chance to negotiate rather than buy.
Missing lines such as professional or cyber, which take longest to quote and bind.

To find the gaps in the first place, use the requirements matrix in how to check your customer contracts against your policies. Reissue certificates only after the policies are corrected; see certificates the seller issued. From now on, route every new contract to your broker before signing.

What does closing the gap look like in practice?

A hypothetical example. A buyer acquires a commercial facilities maintenance company in an asset deal financed with a Small Business Administration (SBA) loan. In the second month, the largest customer, about a quarter of revenue, sends its new vendor agreement. It requires $1,000,000 per occurrence with a $5,000,000 umbrella, additional insured status for ongoing and completed work on a primary and noncontributory basis, waivers of subrogation on general liability, auto and workers' compensation, and $1,000,000 of cyber liability because technicians log into the customer's building systems. The program the buyer bound at closing, copied from the seller's, has a $2,000,000 umbrella, a scheduled additional insured endorsement naming three old customers, a waiver on general liability only, and no cyber policy.

The buyer sends the agreement to the broker. The broker requests a blanket additional insured endorsement covering completed operations, blanket primary and noncontributory wording on general liability (and on auto if the contract asks), and waiver endorsements on general liability, auto and workers' compensation. The broker also requests a $5,000,000 umbrella quote and cyber quotes. Meanwhile the buyer asks the customer for 60 days to comply and asks the customer to accept a lower cyber limit in writing if the quotes at $1,000,000 do not fit. Coverage changes take effect only when the carriers bind and issue the endorsements. The buyer weighs the added premium, which depends on carrier underwriting, against the roughly 25 percent of revenue the contract represents. The figures are illustrative only.

Morrow's contract check can compare a customer agreement's insurance requirements with your policies and flag what is missing, and Morrow can request quotes or endorsements where they make sense. Whether a carrier agrees to a change is up to the carrier.

Keep reading

Frequently asked questions

Is it a breach of contract if my insurance does not meet the customer's requirements?

It can be, because the insurance requirement is usually a term of the contract. Whether it is a breach, and what remedies follow, depends on the contract wording and the governing law. Ask your attorney about any specific agreement.

Can I just send the customer a certificate showing the required coverage?

No. A certificate summarizes the policy and does not add coverage. If the endorsement is not on the policy, a certificate claiming it can mislead the customer and will not help when a claim is made. Fix the policy first.

Are insurance requirements in customer contracts negotiable?

Often, yes. Customers set requirements from templates, and many will accept changes such as an umbrella toward the total limit or removing a coverage that does not fit your work. Get any agreed change in writing.

What is the fastest way to fix additional insured gaps across many contracts?

A blanket additional insured endorsement, which generally extends to parties you agreed in a written contract to add, within the endorsement's terms, can fix many contracts at once. Check that it covers completed work and any other wording your contracts require, and confirm the carrier has issued it.

Who pays if a customer claim comes in before I fix the gap?

It depends on the facts, the contract and the policy. The business may have to cover what the required insurance would have paid. If the gap predates closing, ask your attorney whether the purchase agreement gives you recourse against the seller.

References

Just bought a business? Get your insurance reviewed.

Send Morrow the declarations pages, loss runs and key contracts you inherited. Morrow can review them against the business you bought, flag gaps and request quotes where it makes sense. Any new terms depend on carrier underwriting.

Request a review Check a contract

Morrow · 25 New Chardon Street, 4th Floor, Boston, MA 02114

This article is general information, not legal, tax or financial advice, and not a coverage determination. Coverage depends on the actual policy wording, carrier underwriting, your purchase agreement and your contracts. Ask your attorney and accountant about deal and legal questions.

When Customer Contracts Require Coverage You Do Not Have