11 Bar Insurance Gaps New Owners Find and What to Ask

The gaps worth checking first sit around alcohol. General liability usually excludes liquor claims, the liquor policy may have a limit or form nobody checked, fight (assault and battery) claims may be limited, and property cover can stop short of a dead cooler or a delayed permit. The table shows where each gap hides and the question that closes it. The basic policy list is in what insurance a new bar owner needs.

The short answer

Liquor claims are the first gap. Assume general liability excludes them, and that a landlord named as an additional insured usually gets no liquor cover from that policy either.
The trigger and dates are the second gap. A claims-made liquor policy only reaches service after its retroactive date, as the form defines it, so a change of owner can leave one night uncovered.
Fights are the third. A bar policy may exclude or limit assault and battery claims, so read the endorsement on your own policy.
Business income insurance responds to direct physical loss to property. It is not designed to replace income lost to a license suspension or a permit delay.
Many gaps come from how the bar is run: bands, open-bar parties, leased equipment, to-go cocktails, tipped staff and card payments.

Where can bar policies leave holes?

The table lists eleven gaps, how each shows up and what to ask. None of these is a sign the seller or the seller's broker did a poor job. A program can fit the previous owner and still need changes for you, your lender and your lease.

Common gaps for a new bar owner
Gap and how it shows up	How to spot it	What to ask about
Liquor excluded from general liability. A claim over service of alcohol is turned away	Find the liquor exclusion endorsement and its wording	A liquor liability policy or endorsement with a limit that suits your sales and lease
Liquor limit or form never checked. The limit is below what the lender, landlord or state expects	Declarations page and form list	Whether limit, form and insured parties match each requirement
Seller's liquor policy was claims-made. A claim about a pre-closing night has no policy	Seller's liquor form and its end date	A tail on the old policy, or prior acts on yours
Assault and battery exclusion or sublimit. A fight claim is denied or capped	Read every endorsement, then ask what security practices it expects	The exact wording, and what you must document
Umbrella that skips liquor. Excess limits may not sit above the liquor policy	The umbrella's schedule of underlying insurance	Whether liquor liability is scheduled as underlying cover
Additional insured with no liquor cover. A landlord named on the general liability policy usually gets no liquor cover from it, so the landlord's request to be defended under your policy may be refused	Lease clause beside the endorsement	Whether the liquor policy can add the landlord (the contracts guide covers the lease side)
Equipment, spoilage and code-upgrade costs unclear. A cooler dies or a code upgrade follows a fire	Sublimits and deductibles on the property form	Breakdown, spoilage and code-upgrade cover, and who owns leased gear
Income cover stops at property damage. A permit delay or lease end usually brings no payment under business income cover	The business income trigger wording	Whether any extension applies after a covered loss. Plan permit timing with counsel and your accountant, because the form wording decides
Entertainers treated as contractors. A band member is hurt or an audit adds their pay	Performer agreements and certificates	Written agreements and proof of the contractor's own cover
Tip credit or wage claims. A former server says tips were kept or overtime went unpaid	The employment practices liability insurance (EPLI) form and how it treats wage and hour claims	Whether wage and hour claims are excluded or sublimited, and what the retroactive date is
Card skimmer or point of sale breach. Customer card data is stolen from a terminal	The cyber or crime form	Whether card data and notification costs are covered, and who must give notice

Why does a bar's general liability policy stop at liquor?

The standard Insurance Services Office (ISO) general liability form excludes liquor claims against any insured that is "in the business of" manufacturing, distributing, selling, serving or furnishing alcohol. The exclusion covers causing or adding to someone's intoxication, serving a minor or a person already drunk, and liability under alcohol statutes such as dram shop laws (laws that let an injured person sue the seller of alcohol). A bar is the clearest example of a business in that line. The International Risk Management Institute (IRMI) wrote in 2008 that insurers attach an endorsement to nearly every general liability policy that removes the "in the business of" test, which widens the exclusion. That commentary is old, so read the endorsements on your own policy rather than relying on it.

The exclusion applies to every insured, including additional insureds. A landlord named on your general liability policy usually does not gain liquor cover through it, and a lease that asks for liquor cover is normally met through the liquor policy. Whether an umbrella sits over liquor depends on its schedule of underlying insurance and its own liquor wording, so ask for the answer in writing. The liquor liability page and exclusions that quietly kill coverage explain the mechanics. For umbrella questions see new owner review: umbrella and excess liability.

What happens when a fight spills onto the sidewalk?

A hypothetical example. Two patrons argue near closing. One is hit with a bottle outside and needs surgery. The injured patron's lawyer writes to the bar alleging it over-served the attacker and had no door security. A bartender is also hurt stepping in. Several policies, and several questions, are in play at once:

Assault and battery terms. Does the liability policy exclude the claim, cap it, or cover it only if a security plan was followed?
Liquor liability. Does the over-service allegation trigger it, and is the claim inside its retroactive date if it is claims-made?
Workers' comp. A bartender's injury is an employee claim for workers' comp, if the bar carries it, not for general liability.
Door staff. Were they employees or contractors, and does a certificate exist for any contract security firm?
Documentation. Training records, incident logs and camera footage matter to the insurer and to any plaintiff.

Assault and battery wording is not standardized. Insurers write their own endorsements, so the wording on your policy is the answer. If an exclusion is there, ask whether a narrower version or a security practices condition is available and what the condition would require of you day to day. Availability depends on underwriting.

Which gaps come from how the bar is actually run?

Some holes are not in the forms at all. They open when the way the bar operates drifts away from what the underwriter was told.

Bands, disc jockeys (DJs) and promoters. Ask for a written agreement and a certificate from each. The audit side is in workers' comp, payroll and class codes for a bar or tavern.
Private parties with an open bar. A guest who falls on the stairs raises general liability, and the open bar raises liquor and host liquor questions. Ask whether private events are disclosed to the insurer and covered.
Coat check and valet. Customer coats and cars in your care raise questions that general liability usually does not answer. Ask only if the bar offers those services.
To-go cocktails and delivery. Whether your state allows them and under what license is a regulatory question. If an employee drives a personal car, ask about hired and non-owned auto and whether liquor cover extends off premises.
Leased equipment. Draft systems, coolers, signage and jukeboxes may belong to a distributor or vendor. Property cover responds to what the form says you own or are responsible for.
Cash and card handling. Crime forms differ on whether they cover loss discovered during the policy period or loss that occurs during it. Ask how the form treats inventory that is short without proof of theft. See new owner review: commercial crime and employee theft.

How do you check for these gaps in your first month?

Ask for the complete liquor liability, general liability, property and umbrella forms with every endorsement. A declarations page alone will not show the exclusions. See declarations page vs full policy.
Highlight the words "liquor," "assault," "battery," "security," "retroactive" and "claims-made," and send the clauses to your broker with one question each.
Write down who owns each major piece of equipment and where the agreement is.
List every performer, promoter and security provider, with the agreement and certificate on file.
Compare each requirement in your lease, loan and state license rules with the limits and endorsements you hold. The next step is in contracts, licenses and bonds for a bar or tavern.
Ask what an underwriter will want about your hours, security and training, which is covered in what drives insurance cost for a bar or tavern.

For the general version of this review across owner-run businesses, read 15 coverage gaps new owners find. Morrow can run this check on the documents you inherited, flag what it finds and request quotes where that makes sense. Nothing is in force until a carrier binds it.

Keep reading

Frequently asked questions

How do I find the liquor exclusion in my own policy?

Ask for the complete policy with every endorsement, not just the declarations page, and search for the words liquor, assault, battery, security, retroactive and claims-made. Send each clause to your broker with one question. Your policy wording decides.

Will my insurer deny a claim if a fight breaks out at my bar?

Not automatically. Assault and battery terms are not standardized: an insurer may attach an endorsement that excludes fight claims, limits the amount or sets conditions about security practices. Read the endorsement on your own policy and ask your broker what it requires of the bar.

Will my umbrella policy sit over liquor claims?

It depends on the umbrella's wording and its schedule of underlying insurance. Some umbrellas follow a scheduled liquor policy and some exclude liquor. Ask your broker to confirm in writing.

I only have an hour. Which part of my policy should I read first?

Start with the liquor exclusion and the liquor policy's trigger and retroactive date, because they decide whether the bar's largest exposure has a policy behind it. Then read the assault and battery wording.

My property policy lists the bar's equipment. Is the draft system covered?

Only if the form treats it as property you own or are responsible for. Draft lines, coolers and signage are sometimes owned by a distributor or vendor. Ask who owns each item and whether the property form and any equipment breakdown cover respond to leased gear.

Does my insurance cover a band member who gets hurt on stage?

An employee's injury is normally a workers' comp matter, while an independent performer may or may not carry their own cover. Get a certificate and a written agreement, and see the workers' comp guide for bars for how an audit treats uninsured contractors.

References

Just bought a business? Get your insurance reviewed.

Send Morrow the declarations pages, loss runs and key contracts you inherited. Morrow can review them against the business you bought, flag gaps and request quotes where it makes sense. Any new terms depend on carrier underwriting.

Request a review Check a contract

Morrow · 25 New Chardon Street, 4th Floor, Boston, MA 02114

This article is general information, not legal, tax or financial advice, and not a coverage determination. Coverage depends on the actual policy wording, carrier underwriting, your purchase agreement and your contracts. Ask your attorney and accountant about deal and legal questions.

11 Coverage Gaps New Bar Owners Find, and How to Close Them